Music Blues: Things Haven’t Gone Well – album reviewMusic Blues – Things Haven’t Gone Well (Thrill Jockey)
Out Now


The Harvey Milk bassist releases his debut solo album. Louder Than War’s Paul Scott-Bates reviews.

There’s no doubt, according to the PR info that Stephen Tanner (aka Music Blues) has had a bit of a lousy time of things. Premature birth, depression and the death of a close friend have all taken their toll on him and are reflected on Things Haven’t Gone Well. By the sound of things, they haven’t.

It’s a strange album, which is often good but it’s hard on the ears too. There are no hooks as such, in fact much of the time the album sounds like a sound-check. Guitars strut single reverberating notes against a slow occasional drum clash for what seems every track.

Opener 91771, maybe gives a little promise. A momentous start as guitars rip and drums pound, the album starts with a dramatic opening, if a little long. The same theme continues into second track Premature Caesarean Removal Delivery and the album follows almost the same track throughout.

There are occasional breaks, Teach The Children is a peculiar affair with treated vocals against a backdrop of a blues track which is almost undecipherable. It starts to become quite fascinating must as it fades out after fifty seconds. We’re then back to the formula’ of lone guitar notes with Hopelessness And Worthlessness. Maybe it’s a sign of my age, but I just don’t get ‘it’.

I’m wanting to like the album, and really trying. I can imagine it as a backdrop to a psychological horror movie, maybe the makers of American Horror Story should have a listen. I can imagine dismembered bodies in a dark cellar with a masked and white-cloaked madman soaked in blood not his own. There’s a guitar solo on Trying And Giving Up which breaks the monotony before Great Depression continues.

Perhaps the added complication is that much of the album is instrumental, not necessarily a bad thing but there needs to be more a hook in several of the tracks, and again it’s another shorter interlude track Death March which gives light.

Tanner has to be applauded for his decision to make this album, but it somehow doesn’t quite ‘click’.

More on Music Blues on the Thrill Jockey website here. You can also like on Facebook here.

All words by Paul Scott-Bates. More of Paul’s writing on Louder Than War can be found here. Paul’s website is hiapop Blog. Paul is working hard to save Radio Lancashire’s On The Wire, the BBCs longest running alternative music programme. Follow him on twitter as @saveonthewire for all On The Wire news or follow hiapop Blog on Twitter, @hiapop.

Previous articleWanted! Alt-country, Folk-punk, Blues/Americana artists/bands. Could you set these original lyrics to music?
Next articleCity Reign: When You Got It All – single review
Born and bred in Lancashire, currently residing in the Rossendale Valley. Everything deserves one listen, but, not necessarily a second. Only (ex-Community) DJ to ever play Nat ‘King’Cole followed by Nine Inch Nails, and, eat Fish and Chips live on air.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here