John Cale © Melanie Smith
John Cale © Melanie Smith

John Cale © Melanie Smith

Velvet Underground & Nico Re-imagined
John Cale + Special Guests
Friday May 27th 2017
Clarence Docks, Liverpool

With a smorgasbord of guest singers and musicians, it was a pleasure to see this one-off event on the docks of Liverpool, which also plays host to the excellent Liverpool Sound City festival.  James Lowther (words) and Melanie Smith (photos) report back for Louder Than War.

Seeing a legendary musician from a legendary band is always a special experience, and John Cale was no exception – particularly when the performance is celebrating the 50th anniversary of one of the greatest albums of all time.

The sun was shining over the waters and the event was a sell-out, so anticipation was high by the time I arrived. The crowd was a real mixed bag with teenagers younger than myself mingling with people who lived through The Velvet Underground in their heyday.

Kicking things off with a storming performance of ‘I’m Waiting for the Man’, it was the second track – the unparalleled ‘White Light/White Heat’ – that showcased the genius of what the night had in store for us. With guest vocals and instrumentals from The Kills, each song brought a new guest and a new re-imagining of the timeless work of John Cale and co.

Some of the collaborations worked exceptionally well. Fat White Family, and Lias Kaci Saoudi’s vocals in particular, managed to capture the scuzzy edge that the Velvet Underground have become renowned for – particularly during the exceptional ‘Heroin’ towards the end of the night. This was music you’d find in a dive bar in the middle of New York, after all, and FWF perfectly encapsulated that gritty energy.

John Cale & Fat White Family © Melanie Smith

Others, like Wild Beasts, made no attempt to recapture that rawness. Instead, they utilising their soaring vocals and electronic styling to give ‘I’ll Be Your Mirror’ a modern day makeover. Moments like this were clear highlights, and it was clear that these were musicians who had grown up with and been influenced by The Velvet Underground.

Cale himself had a blast on stage, and his talent was astounding. At 75 years old, he flitted from instrument to instrument and even performed lead vocals on a couple of tracks. There had been a few sound issues throughout the set, made worse by the fact that the wind was blowing the sound out across the water, but I feel like I can let this slide.

Unfortunately, some of the collaborations didn’t work quite so well. Clinic were pleasant enough, but lacked the passion of some of the other performers. Gruff Rhys (of Super Furry Animals fame) struggled too, particularly when presented with some of the more obscure and challenging material (Lady Godiva especially felt like a real slog to get through).

There were a couple of standout highlights though. I particularly enjoyed Nadine Shah’s performance, with the goth-pop singer perfectly encapsulating the sultry vocals of Nico for ‘Femme Fatale’. On a personal level, it was poignant to see the whole crowd fall silent for a minute to remember the victims of the Manchester Arena tragedy.

The finale was bonkers. So much so that I didn’t manage to endure the whole thing as all the guests came onto the stage to play a longer version of an already long track – ‘Sister Ray’. For some, this was no doubt a highlight, but for me it felt like a slog. I’d later find out this song went on for more than half an hour – I love Velvet Underground, but not quite that much!

It was certainly an experience, and one that will likely not to be repeated. Despite the issues, I am incredibly glad that I went and hope that we continue to see performances as innovative as this in the future.

Photo gallery:

Please note: Use of these images in any form without permission is illegal. If you wish to use /purchase or license any images please contact

You can find more about John Cale at his website here, and Twitter, or Facebook.

All words by James Lowther. More writing by James on Louder Than War can be found at his author’s archive.

Photos by Melanie Smith. More work by Mel on Louder Than War can be found at her author’s archive. You can find her on Facebook and Twitter. Photography portfolio can be found here

Previous articleLISTEN! Liam Gallagher’s new single ‘Wall Of Glass’
Next articleSTREET EATERS truewave punks release 3rd full length


  1. I also went to this show, but for me it was disappointing. The venue itself was poor, standing on rough rubble and queuing 40 mins for a drink wasn’t my idea of fun. The show itself suffered from 3 main issues – 1. John Cale’s singing days are behind him and someone in his entourage needs to tell him that. The music on the opener Waiting for my Man was terrific, but his vocal was like bad kareoke. 2. Using so many singers was inevitably hit and miss, but as much as anything it robbed the show of any momentum. It never really hit its stride. 3. The PA was far too small for an outdoor venue. Whole songs literally disappeared with the wind.
    These songs were born in scuzzy New York clubs in the 60’s, I’m not sure a windswept industrial estate in Liverpool docks is thier best home.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here