An open letter to Robbie Williams; his call for more political musicDear Mr. Williams,

We hear on the grapevine that you have asked for more bands to ‘rebel’ and that there are not enough outspoken artists out there these days.

It’s an intriguing statement and one we wholeheartedly agree with- even if we know of many bands and musicians who still have the old something to say thing going on but can’t get on the radio because it’s, ironically, clogged up with Take That and fellow shampoo entertainers. (although we have a soft spot of Take That having met Mark Owen and Jason Orange and found them very down to earth and switched on people).


We are glad you are wondering about things though but it does make us think, why let everyone else do the dirty work- why don’t you do something yourself?

Robbie, you may feel like you are just a mere family entertainer, a singing clown that no-one takes seriously but we acknowledge the flashes of inspiration in your music and that you have the ability to write really good lyrics within the pop format and that you have worked with really good songwriters from the more rebellious side of the equation. In short you seem to be a lot more than a dancing bear and there seems to be a genuine tingle of passion and humanity in your soul which is all too rare in your part of the pop world.


Just because you were in a boy band it doesn’t mean that you can’t have a brain and be connected with the world- although it often helps! It’s a great start to acknowledge this but you can take it further, like we said- we dare you to try.

It seems like you know all this already as you told the Sun (of all papers) last week.

“There has not been that same spirit ever since (Britpop), I don’t think. There used to be something to rebel against. I think there is plenty to rebel against right now, especially with what is happening with the world, with how people are being treated by governments and the recession. Normally this is the time of great upheaval and great voices that rise and say, ‘No we are not fucking having this’.”
 But there seems to be a great apathy. Where are the Billy Braggs and The Clashes? It’s good to have a place to go and complain. Not than I’m doing anything about it, I’m in a mansion in Los Angeles. What do I know?”

At least you had the humility and sense of reality to put the bit at the end on (something that some of my generation punk heroes won’t acknowledge in their own lives) but there is no reason to feel you can’t do anything because you are living in la-la land- it doesn’t stop lots of other millionaire entertainers from doing their bit.

Of course no-one is asking you to be the Clash and no-one is claiming that there is a league table of cultural credibility. Some of the most inspiring pop records don’t have any meaning and some of the most earnest records are really boring. We were just intrigued by your comment and wondered if you wanted to have a go or if you were going help those that are trying to say something or if it was just a  casual aside…


Which brings us back to our question really, instead of asking everyone else to do your dirty work- why don’t you do something?


Do you feel that people will laugh, I mean they will, they always do. Do you think no-one will take you seriously? No-one expects you to write a Crass style album- but you are a pretty good lyric writer and it doesn’t have to be sloganeering- that kind of stuff never works anyway. You don’t even have to sing a load of political songs- you got the money, you got the media space- there’s loads of ways you can get involved.


Don’t be ashamed of being the fuck puppet for the field full of middle aged ladies- that’s a cool job and one that has great importance as well, there is nothing lightweight about being the sex monkey for a generation but it’s great to see that your mind is also twitching into action. If you don’t want to do it go and fund the career of a struggling young protest singer- we know you already put money into grass roots stuff.

Or you could come and join us on a few campaigns we got lined up this summer, you’re welcome to join in and do what you like- sing a few songs, show your face or just lug some amps around, I dunno, it’s up to you.

The world is fucked up and it’s always awkward for the well off winners in the great capitalist scramble to criticise the very system that made them the shiny young kings of the new Rome but there are so many ways that you can use that space and privilege and, Robbie, we dare you try…


Previous articleOrchestre Poly-Rythmo De Contonou: Vol 3 – The Skeletal Essences Of Afro Funk – album review
Next articleThe Godfathers: Jukebox Fury – album review
Award winning journalist and boss of Louder Than War. In a 30 year music writing career, John was the first to write about bands such as Stone Roses and Nirvana and has several best selling music books to his name. He constantly tours the world with Goldblade and the Membranes playing gigs or doing spoken word and speaking at music conferences.


  1. I’m a bit fucked off with this people who got rich in the 90’s and live in million pound houses telling us that there is no rebellious music any more … maybe in their world … but in my world there is lots … I’m a big fan of Primal Scream but Bobby Gillespie has been spouting the same shit … How about put your money where you mouth is an set up a label and sign a load of these bands and promote them … cause no one else is helping the proper bands out … every meeting ive had with a label has resulted in them demanding I change my lyrics to be less political … safe to say were still unsigned … Someone with a wad of cash needs to take a chance on half a dozen decent acts and go for it … I’ll name some now … Roughneck Riot, Cyanide Pills, Sky Rocket Jack, and even my band The Yalla Yallas … Every one of our acts gives everything we got … and for as much respect I have for Robbie Williams and Bobby Gillespie it doesnt give them the right to start pissing all over a scene they know knack all about … your so far removed … invest in us!!!

  2. I wholeheartedly agree with this post! Fund me, you cheeky scallywag: httpss://

  3. I am still laughing about Phil Collins and his “Another Day in Paradise”.
    He really cared didn’t he………….not.

  4. KynchinLay PUBLIC EXECUTION…. self funded single and out this week!!! go and check it out :)

  5. I’m a Take That fan (I was a teen in the 90’s, don’t judge) and I totally agree with this. THIS is who Robbie Williams is, he makes an album, and he would talk A LOT about everything but his music. Even if it’s a great album, you will learn more about his private life, private parts and eccentricities instead of his music. Like I said I was a teenager in he 90’s and pop music holds a special place in my heart, but now, if I have to choose a new artist to listen to I’d go more with folk/indie musicians/bands instead of pop. I don’t think Robbie listens to other than commercial pop or whatever is on the radio to be honest, he obviously doesn’t know about artists whom, like Rob Galloway says, can’t get a record deal because they refuse to sell themselves to the system of labels, and as a result, the Rihannas and Justin Biebers are signed up instead of them. I wouldn’t be surprised if this weeks he blogs saying “You know what, there ARE artist who protest and are involve in changing the music industry”, he might do that because of his habit, “talk first, think later”. And yeah, you go to The Sun to ask for more political music, try again Rob.

  6. Any blog that contains the words “fuck puppet” and “sex monkey” gets my thumbs up, infact I think Robbie should include these as lyrics in his “rebel song” go on Robbie I dare ya!

  7. “Don’t be ashamed of being the fuck puppet for the field full of middle aged ladies”

    What a horrible thing to say?
    Firstly, just because he is “Marketed” as that by the money-men, doesn’t mean that he is that.
    Secondly, female sensuality, reduced to regarding a musician the way sad men regard porn? What are you thinking? That’s silly.
    Thirdly, I don’t think you have the right to talk down to a fellow human being like that, let alone a fellow performer. Its so disrespectful and malicious.
    Fourthly, ever heard of a law called deformation of character? Mr Williams’ lawyer would have fun with this open letter.
    Lastly, if the level of writing on LTW has sunk so low, I’m outa here.

  8. I’d like to hear Robbie team-up with his fellow musicians from “The Potteries”, Discharge, and do a 21st Century remake of ”WHY?’; one of the finest protest albums of all time.

  9. I Don’t Think Your “Reading” His Lyrics From The Right Perspective??? He Says A Lot And It Isn’t Love Song Stuff Neither!! Mind You, Very Few So Called Love Songs Aren’t……Elvis!…..I Mean! Come on? How Historically Political Do You Want? He Has The “Advertising Space” And He Uses It……It’s Just Well Veiled With Shit. I Raise My Hand To The Guy.

  10. i agree with rob because i know from experience that people want musicians to be singing/dancing monkeys, i write meaningful lyrics and then get told of by my musical mentor at elfm because it isnt his type of music (indie/pop) and i am the only one interested in a dying art of playing rockabilly/punk/blues but much more recently psychobilly, i have share my experiences of the world through my music with passion and enthusiasm but they cant handle anyone with a mind of their own


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here